Shemar Stewart's Contract Standoff with the Bengals: A Deep Dive into the NFL Rookie Dispute

The Cincinnati Bengals and their first-round draft pick, Shemar Stewart, are currently locked in a contract impasse. This situation escalated recently when Stewart left mandatory minicamp, raising questions about the future of this promising defensive end.

What is the Dispute About?

According to sources close to the negotiations, the main issue revolves around contract language that could void guaranteed money in future years. For instance, if Stewart were suspended for on-field infractions like leading with the crown of his helmet, it could eliminate future guarantees. This has become a significant sticking point, especially given the increased importance of guaranteed roster bonuses in recent years.

League Reactions and Perspectives

This standoff has drawn attention across the NFL, with many labeling it as a typical Bengals scenario. The team is also in a similar situation with Trey Hendrickson, who has vowed not to play under his current contract after leading the NFL in sacks last year. The Bengals' history of contract disputes, including the departure of All-Pro safety Jessie Bates III in 2023, adds to the narrative.

An NFL agent familiar with the Bengals' front office described them as "comfortable with the uncomfortable," suggesting that they rarely relent in such negotiations. Stewart and his agent, Zac Hiller, appear equally determined, setting the stage for a potentially prolonged standoff.

Options for Stewart and the Bengals

The Bengals hold Stewart's rights, but the NFL's collective bargaining agreement allows for several scenarios. If the Bengals fail to sign Stewart by August 5, they cannot trade him. Another critical deadline is November 11; if Stewart hasn't signed by then, he becomes ineligible to play for the rest of the season. If he sits out the entire season, he can re-enter the 2026 draft, with every team except the Bengals eligible to pick him.

Bengals' Official Stance

Bengals coach Zac Taylor has expressed optimism about Stewart's future with the team, comparing his absence to the 2020 season when there were no offseason workouts due to the COVID-19 pandemic. Taylor emphasized that there is still time to resolve the issue and get Stewart back on the field.

Bengals center Ted Karras, who is also a vice president for the NFLPA, supports Stewart's efforts to protect his guaranteed money. Karras highlighted the importance of maximizing guarantees for players, reflecting the NFLPA's broader stance on contract negotiations.

Conclusion

As the standoff continues, both sides have significant decisions to make. The outcome will not only impact Stewart's career but also set a precedent for future rookie negotiations in the NFL. The coming weeks will be crucial in determining whether a resolution can be reached or if this dispute will extend into the regular season.