Mohamed Salah's Defensive Dilemma: How Liverpool's Tactical Imbalance Threatens Their Title Ambitions
Examining how Mohamed Salah's limited defensive contributions expose Liverpool's tactical flaws against elite opponents, with insights into Arne Slot's system and potential solutions.




Liverpool's Right-Side Conundrum Under Scrutiny
Mohamed Salah's attacking prowess remains undisputed, but his limited defensive engagement has emerged as a critical tactical challenge for Liverpool. Recent matches against top-tier opponents like Chelsea revealed systemic vulnerabilities:
- 39% of Chelsea's attacks targeted Liverpool's right flank (BBC Match Data)
- Fullbacks face 2v1 overloads due to Salah's advanced positioning
- Midfield cover struggles to compensate during transitions
Visual: Liverpool's right-side exposure against Chelsea's left-wing attacks
The Salah Paradox: Freedom vs. Responsibility
Manager Arne Slot faces a delicate balancing act:
- Offensive Priority: Salah's 28 goal contributions last season justify his advanced role
- Defensive Trade-off: Opposition teams exploit space behind Egypt's record scorer
- Systemic Solutions Required: Midfield rotations and fullback support mechanisms
"When you have a world-class finisher, you build systems to maximize their strengths," notes Sky Sports analyst Jamie Carragher. "But elite opponents will ruthlessly exploit any imbalance."
Comparative Tactical Approaches
Team | Star Attacker | Defensive Support System |
---|---|---|
Liverpool | Mohamed Salah | Isolated right-back |
Manchester City | Phil Foden | Double pivot + inverted fullback |
Arsenal | Bukayo Saka | Overlapping midfielder system |
Three Critical Fixes for Slot's System
-
Midfield Recalibration
- Implement staggered pressing triggers
- Improve spatial awareness in transition
- Develop rotational cover patterns
-
Fullback Evolution
- Test hybrid RB/CB partnerships
- Utilize Trent Alexander-Arnold's playmaking when fit
- Adjust positioning based on opponent strength
-
Salah's Selective Tracking
- Implement situational defensive responsibilities
- Create counter-pressing traps in advanced areas
- Optimize recovery sprints through fitness monitoring
The Bigger Picture: Liverpool's Title Credentials
Despite recent struggles, underlying numbers suggest potential:
- xG Differential: +1.4 per game (3rd in Premier League)
- Possession: 58.7% average (2nd behind Manchester City)
- Key Passes: 12.3 per game (1st in league)
"This isn't about Salah becoming a defender," argues The Athletic's James Pearce. "It's about engineering collective solutions that protect his attacking output while shoring up defensive stability."
Upcoming Fixtures: Litmus Test for Adjustments
Date | Opponent | Tactical Challenge |
---|---|---|
19 Oct | Manchester City | Guardiola's flank overloads |
26 Oct | Tottenham | Udogie's marauding runs |
2 Nov | Aston Villa | Digne's crossing threat |
Data via Opta Sports: Liverpool face 3/5 of last season's top six in next month
Conclusion: Evolution Over Revolution
While critics highlight Liverpool's defensive frailties, the solution lies in tactical refinement rather than Salah's complete reinvention. As Slot works to implement hybrid defensive schemes and improve midfield coordination, the Reds' title hopes depend on finding equilibrium between their Egyptian king's attacking magic and collective defensive solidity.