With Derek Carr announcing his retirement, the New Orleans Saints face immediate questions about their quarterback position. Carr, 34, sustained a labral tear and significant degenerative changes to his rotator cuff, making his 2025 season uncertain. The Saints, who went 0-7 last season without Carr, now must decide how to proceed with their young quarterbacks: Tyler Shough, Spencer Rattler, and Jake Haener.

What Does Carr's Retirement Mean for the Saints?

The Saints were prepared for the possibility of playing without Carr, but his retirement during rookie minicamp provides clarity. This allows the team to focus on developing their young quarterbacks without the distraction of Carr's uncertain status. The coaching staff can now tailor the offense to suit Shough, Rattler, or Haener, ensuring a smoother transition into the upcoming season.

Will the Saints Bring in Another Quarterback?

Coach Kellen Moore has the flexibility to shape the quarterback room as he sees fit. While the Saints have three young quarterbacks, they might consider adding a veteran to mentor the group. Alternatively, they could stick with their current roster and focus on developing their young talent.

What Are the Salary Cap Implications?

Carr was due to make $40 million this season, but his retirement means the Saints will not have to pay his $30 million base salary. However, he retains a $10 million signing bonus. This move helps the Saints manage their salary cap more effectively as they plan for the 2026 season.

Is Carr's Retirement Permanent?

While it's possible Carr could attempt a comeback, most insiders believe his retirement is permanent. Recovering from a serious shoulder injury at 34 is a daunting challenge, and Carr has already earned over $200 million in his career. His legacy as a durable and underrated quarterback who made four Pro Bowls will be remembered, even if he couldn't lead a team to a championship.

What is Derek Carr's Legacy?

Carr's career was marked by resilience and consistency. Despite playing for multiple head coaches and coordinators, he remained a reliable starter and made four Pro Bowls. While he never won a playoff game, his ability to perform under challenging circumstances solidified his place as one of the NFL's most underrated quarterbacks.