The 2025 MLB season has been a rollercoaster of performances, with some players exceeding expectations and others falling short. Here’s a detailed look at the updated top 50 player rankings and what the experts have to say about the changes.

Who’s Ranked Too High?

Buster Olney questions the placement of Nick Kurtz above seasoned players like Freddie Freeman and Pete Alonso. Kurtz, with only 285 career plate appearances, seems out of place compared to Freeman’s 357 career home runs and Alonso’s recent franchise record-tying performance.

David Schoenfield critiques Juan Soto’s ranking, arguing that while Soto has been a top player in the past, his 2025 performance doesn’t justify the 12th spot. Soto’s batting average and clutch hitting have been subpar, despite his home run and walk numbers.

Who’s Ranked Too Low?

Jesse Rogers believes Nathan Eovaldi deserves a higher spot than No. 39. Despite injury setbacks, Eovaldi has been dominant, boasting a 1.71 ERA and a 10-3 record. His recent eight-inning shutout against the New York Yankees highlights his value.

Bradford Doolittle points to Cristopher Sánchez’s rapid rise, suggesting he should be in the 10-to-12 range. Sánchez’s trajectory is impressive, and he’s a strong contender in the NL Cy Young race.

Who Could Make Us Look Silly?

Alden Gonzalez highlights Ronald Acuna Jr.’s potential to make the rankings look foolish. Despite limited playing time due to injuries, Acuna’s performance when healthy has been electrifying, and his impending return could shake up the list.

Looking Back at the Preseason List

Kiley McDaniel notes that Manny Machado has validated his preseason ranking with a bounce-back season, now sitting at No. 17. David Schoenfield acknowledges that Corbin Carroll’s consistent ranking at No. 18 was a correct call, despite his sophomore slump.

What Did We Get Wrong?

Bradford Doolittle admits Nathan Eovaldi’s absence from the preseason list was a mistake, given his stellar performance. Alden Gonzalez laments the exclusion of relievers like Josh Hader and Aroldis Chapman, who could be pivotal in the postseason.

Most Surprising Change

Kyle Stowers’ breakout season is the most unexpected shift. From a career WAR of -0.9 to hitting .286/.364/.544 with 25 homers, Stowers has been a revelation.

Conclusion

The 2025 MLB season continues to surprise, with player rankings reflecting both expected performances and unexpected turns. As the season progresses, these rankings will undoubtedly evolve, keeping fans and experts on their toes.