Conor McGregor's Legal Battle: Evidence Withdrawal Sparks Prosecution Referral

Conor McGregor's appeal case takes a dramatic turn as evidence withdrawal leads to a referral to Irish prosecutors. Learn more about the ongoing legal battle.

The legal saga surrounding former MMA fighter Conor McGregor continues to unfold as Ireland's Court of Appeal has decided to refer a critical matter in his case to the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP). This development follows McGregor's dramatic withdrawal of proposed new evidence during his appeal hearing.

Background of the Case

McGregor was ordered to pay Nikita Hand over €248,000 (£206,000) in damages after a jury found him guilty of sexually assaulting her in a Dublin hotel in December 2018. The High Court ruling last year also mandated McGregor to cover her legal costs.

The Appeal Hearing

The Court of Appeal hearing concluded on Wednesday, with a full decision expected at a later date. Notably, McGregor has not appeared in court since the appeal began on Tuesday.

Evidence Withdrawal

On the second day of the hearing, McGregor's legal team unexpectedly withdrew proposed new evidence from Samantha O'Reilly and Steven Cummins, former neighbors of Nikita Hand. This evidence, which McGregor believed could suggest that Hand's injuries were caused by a former partner, was met with skepticism. Hand's lawyer described the claims as "lies," and she was prepared to testify against them.

Legal Team's Justification

McGregor's barrister cited the inadmissibility of supporting evidence and the lack of corroboration for O'Reilly's testimony as reasons for the withdrawal. The court's three-judge panel expressed confusion over the decision, with one judge stating they were "bemused" by the reasoning.

Prosecution Referral

Hand's lawyer argued that the withdrawn evidence had been widely circulated in the media, potentially undermining her reputation. He requested the court to refer the matter to the DPP, a request the court granted.

Co-Accused's Appeal

In a related development, James Lawrence, who was accused alongside McGregor, appealed the decision not to award him costs after the jury found he did not assault Hand. Lawrence's barrister argued that "costs follow events," but the court noted that McGregor had paid Lawrence's legal fees, complicating the matter.

Conclusion

This case continues to draw significant attention, highlighting the complexities of legal battles involving high-profile figures. The referral to the DPP marks a pivotal moment in McGregor's ongoing legal challenges.

What to Read Next

Paul Craig Retires After Legendary UFC Career: A Tribute to Scotland's MMA Icon
MMA

Paul Craig Retires After Legendary UFC Career: A Tribute to Scotland's MMA Icon

Scotland's UFC legend Paul Craig retires after a knockout loss to Modestas Bukauskas, marking the end of an illustrious 29-fight career.

Rhys McKee Faces Axel Sola in High-Stakes UFC Welterweight Clash in Paris
MMA

Rhys McKee Faces Axel Sola in High-Stakes UFC Welterweight Clash in Paris

Rhys McKee aims to continue his UFC momentum against undefeated newcomer Axel Sola in a thrilling welterweight bout at UFC Fight Night Paris.

Mason Jones Dominates in Spectacular UFC Paris Comeback
MMA

Mason Jones Dominates in Spectacular UFC Paris Comeback

Welsh fighter Mason Jones stages an impressive comeback at UFC Paris, securing a decisive victory over Bolaji Oki.

Dwayne Johnson's Transformation: From Blockbuster Star to MMA Fighter in 'The Smashing Machine'
MMA

Dwayne Johnson's Transformation: From Blockbuster Star to MMA Fighter in 'The Smashing Machine'

Dwayne Johnson's raw performance as UFC fighter Mark Kerr in 'The Smashing Machine' marks a significant shift from his blockbuster roles, earning critical acclaim and Oscar buzz.

Khamzat Chimaev's Triumphant Return to the UFC: A New Chapter in MMA History
MMA

Khamzat Chimaev's Triumphant Return to the UFC: A New Chapter in MMA History

Khamzat Chimaev credits Donald Trump for his return to the UFC, facing Dricus du Plessis in a highly anticipated middleweight title fight at UFC 319.

Fabian Edwards' Unbelievable Journey: From Amateur Chaos to PFL Middleweight Glory
MMA

Fabian Edwards' Unbelievable Journey: From Amateur Chaos to PFL Middleweight Glory

Fabian Edwards shares his incredible journey from an amateur MMA fighter to the PFL Middleweight Tournament final, highlighting his resilience and determination.

Gina Carano Settles Legal Battle with Disney Over Mandalorian Firing: A New Chapter Begins
MMA

Gina Carano Settles Legal Battle with Disney Over Mandalorian Firing: A New Chapter Begins

Former MMA fighter Gina Carano settles her lawsuit with Disney over her dismissal from The Mandalorian, marking a new chapter in her career.

Kiefer Crosbie Condemns Referee Decision After Controversial UFC Fight in China
MMA

Kiefer Crosbie Condemns Referee Decision After Controversial UFC Fight in China

Kiefer Crosbie criticizes referee Marc Goddard for a controversial decision during his UFC fight in China, highlighting the risks of rushing concussed fighters back into the octagon.

Sean Strickland Faces Six-Month Ban Following Cage Brawl at MMA Event
MMA

Sean Strickland Faces Six-Month Ban Following Cage Brawl at MMA Event

Former UFC champion Sean Strickland has been suspended for six months after a cage brawl at a Las Vegas MMA event. Learn more about the incident and its consequences.

Lerone Murphy's Spectacular Knockout at UFC 319: A New Featherweight Contender Emerges
MMA

Lerone Murphy's Spectacular Knockout at UFC 319: A New Featherweight Contender Emerges

Lerone Murphy stakes his claim for the UFC featherweight title with a sensational knockout of Aaron Pico at UFC 319, positioning himself as a top contender.

Volkanovski vs. Murphy: The Ultimate Featherweight Showdown
MMA

Volkanovski vs. Murphy: The Ultimate Featherweight Showdown

Featherweight champion Alexander Volkanovski gears up to defend his title against rising star Lerone Murphy in a highly anticipated UFC bout.

Historic UFC Event Confirmed at the White House: A Landmark in Sports and Politics
MMA

Historic UFC Event Confirmed at the White House: A Landmark in Sports and Politics

Dana White confirms a groundbreaking UFC event at the White House on July 4th, marking a historic fusion of sports and political celebration.

Dakota Ditcheva Triumphs Over Sumiko Inaba Despite Hand Injury at PFL Champions Series
MMA

Dakota Ditcheva Triumphs Over Sumiko Inaba Despite Hand Injury at PFL Champions Series

Dakota Ditcheva overcomes a hand injury to dominate Sumiko Inaba at the PFL Champions Series in South Africa, extending her unbeaten streak to 15 fights.

Alfie Davis Overcomes Impostor Syndrome to Secure Life-Changing PFL Final Bout
MMA

Alfie Davis Overcomes Impostor Syndrome to Secure Life-Changing PFL Final Bout

Alfie Davis reflects on overcoming impostor syndrome to secure a life-changing bout in the PFL lightweight tournament final against Gadzhi Rabadanov.

Paddy Pimblett on the Brink of UFC Lightweight Title Shot Against Ilia Topuria
MMA

Paddy Pimblett on the Brink of UFC Lightweight Title Shot Against Ilia Topuria

Paddy Pimblett is just one fight away from a UFC lightweight title shot, with Ilia Topuria ready to challenge him. Discover the latest in MMA 2025.

Load More

We use essential cookies to make our site work. With your consent, we may also use non-essential cookies to improve user experience and analyze website traffic. By clicking "Accept," you agree to our website's cookie use as described in our Cookie Policy.